OK, so we’ve been given a TON of info in the episode. I love the pendulum, very cool
. Dharma doesn’t seem to be a mystery now (to me at least). I guess they are (were) a scientific organization working on the island doing experiments with biology and electromagnetism. The one thing that I am confused about though, is are they still around? In season 1, there was a Dharma supplies drop, so they must be still around and still think they have functioning operatives on the island (at least until Keamey shows up). But they haven’t been in the story line for a while…or have they?
So here’s my theory…Widmore is Hanso. The Dharma Inititive is his company that he set up to exploit the island in his quest for power. This is why Richard and the Other-Others battled against Dharma in the past and recruited Ben to help them wipe Dharma out on the island. They want Widmore to stop the exploitation of the island. I think that after that Widmore, at some point, was banished from ever returning to the island, which is why he needed the Initiative to get back to it. I think he dedicated his life and resources to finding that Island again, and when he did (using the pendulum)
This theory also explains a little bit more about the confrontation with Ben and the we-can’t kill-each-other pact they have. Ben clearly made a deal with Widmore after Richard assisted him in destroying the Dharma Initiative on the island. What tht deal is, is still a secret, but I am sure we’ll find out.
Think about it, Widmore protects his interests in the island by masquerading as Alvar Hanso. That way he can keep his legitimate enterprises going, while he keeps the more clandestined “Island” business going.
Thoughts?

This is an interesting and well thought out theory. However, there is another mystery for which I currently have no theory’s or ideas of, perhaps you can help me with it: The mystery of the missing podcast. You guys recorded it weeks ago and yet, when I check the site – no new podcast.
It’s only the whole reason for this site right? Or perhaps I am mistaken, perhaps a wall of text about Charles Widmore takes precedence. Seriously though, I love a good lost post as much (if not more) than anyone but c’mon Chuck, give us podcasts.
Isn’t he trying to find the island? Wouldn’t he have as much or more info than the old bat in the basement with the giant pendulum?
Chuck, you just got pwned….n00b
I have a slightly different theory, but closely related. Try this:
Early 1940’s: Richard Alpert is told by Jacob to visit the mainland, and find a very special young boy named Charles Widmore. Alpert gives Widmore a test, and unlike a young John Locke, Widmore passes the test. Alpert takes Widmore to the island, and raises him among the Others.
Early 1970’s: After around 30 years on the island, Widmore has risen to a leadership post, and for some reason, turns the wheel, moving the island, exiling himself and waking up in the Tunisian desert.
Widmore is desperate to either get back, or find a way to use the power of the island. He convinces a man named Hanso, along with a pair of Michigan grad students named the DeGroots, to fund a project called the Dharma Initiative. He informs them of the island, and with the help of Eloise Hawking, they build a station that allows them to find the island.
1992: Ben is instrumental in The Purge, which wipes out the Dharma Initiative. Ben gets everything he had by taking it from Charles Widmore. Widmore begins to plot how to get back to the island.
My reasoning: First, Widmore had to have lied when he told Locke that Ben tricked him into moving the island. Ben had to blow a hole in the Orchid Station in order to get to the wheel, so the island clearly hadn’t been moved since before Dharma. This scenario solves that problem. Second, it solves the “three decades” problem. Widmore didn’t say that his three decades started when he first met Locke. Third, it solves the Penny birth problem. If Penny is in her 30s in 2004, that means she was born in the 1970s, which is around the Dharma time. If Widmore had been on the island then, he would have either had to send Penny’s mother away, or have adopted her. Either are possible, but unnecessary in this scenario. Fourth, it solves the problem of how DI new to look for the island in the first place. Hawking said that her station was used to find the island in the first place, but the only way they would have known that there was an island to find was if someone told them, like Widmore. Fifth, it solves the problem of how Keamy knew about the Orchid. That had to have been one of the most secretive parts of DI, and if Widmore had been connected to DI, he could have known about it.
I’m still working out the details, but this story ties together a lot of loose ends.
One more point: I don’t think Ben and Charles had a deal about not killing each other. Instead, they both know that they have a destiny, and that neither can die before they fulfill it (think of when Michael tried to kill himself, or when Keamy tried to shoot Michael). It is more about the “rules” that Faraday and Hawking mentioned.